College freshman Joe is new to school when he mistakes a rush invitation for a come-on from a cute fraternity brother. He's no less confused when a hazing ritual between him and Christian, his "big brother" in the Greek system, takes an intense and intimate turn. After Joe sets Christian "straight" about his sexual interests, Christian confesses that he himself is straight - but with "issues". A twisted love triangle forms when the confused Christian turns a romantic weekend getaway with his girlfriend into a double-date; inviting along his gay sibling Michael and "little brother" Joe. Trouble starts when Michael and Joe hit it off and Christian is left to face his own issues, straight or otherwise.